A Picture and a Thousand Words

When my wife and I were dating, and things started to get serious, I took her home to meet my family. They wasted no time in breaking out the family photo albums and began to dissect my life picture by picture. There were the cute baby pictures, pictures of the major accomplishments, and more embarrassing photos than I knew existed. One by one my wife got little glimpses into the life of the man she was growing deeper in love with.

Each picture had a story behind it, containing details one could never learn from the picture itself. My family spent hours reminiscing, sharing their memories of good times and bad. By the end of the day my wife had gotten a good look at the person I was and how I grew into the person I currently am. The photos, however good, were not enough to do this. It was only with my family’s memories of the events that a proper understanding could be obtained.

The bible is the photo album of salvation history. The words on the page create the images in the mind that the stories are meant to convey. The album begins with creation itself and follows the journey of mankind through the fall to its salvation and redemption. As with my family, God’s family has reminisced about these stories throughout time. The Jewish oral tradition has meticulously passed down the stories of the Old Testament from one generation to the next. Likewise, the Catholic Church has done the same with both the Old and New Testaments through her Sacred Oral Tradition. Holy Scripture and Sacred Oral Tradition make up the deposit of faith that defines what Catholics believe and why. It is only through the written word and the Sacred Oral Tradition that a complete and accurate understanding of salvation history can be obtained. The story is incomplete and misunderstood if either is missing.

Catholic oral tradition was successfully used to combat the Luther heresies. When Luther decided to cast aside 1500 years of Church teaching to begin his own ecclesial community based upon his personal opinion he did away with Sacred Tradition. He kept only the photo album which he could explain in any way he saw fit to support his opinions. He made the claim that anyone, inspired by the Holy Spirit, could come to the correct understanding of Holy Scripture. That, after all, is what the Jews believed about the Septuagint, the Greek version of the Old Testament.

Two things would have happened if what Luther claimed were true. The first is that everyone, divinely inspired, would come to the same understanding as what was taught by the Church for 1500 years. Holy Scripture itself says this in 1 Timothy 3:15 –

“…the church (through her magisterium) is the pillar and bulwark of the truth.”

Second, if everyone can come to the correct understanding of Holy Scripture for themselves, we would not have, at last count, over 70,000 different versions of the truth proclaimed by the various denominational and nondenominational Christian churches throughout the world. We all would share the same truth and have the same understanding of what the photos in the photo album mean.

Luther was dubbed the father of the reformation. Revolution would be a more accurate word. If we were to call Luther for what he is truly the father of it would be Christian moral relativism. When he taught that every person could define what the bible means for themselves, he opened the doors for everyone to define what is right and wrong for themselves. The Church ceased to be the pillar and bulwark of the truth, as the bible says, and truth became a matter of person opinion. Now the tens of thousands of churches that exist throughout the world cannot even agree on something as simple and straightforward as the Ten Commandments.

The Church is the pillar and bulwark of the truth, as scripture says it is. It is not just any church or every church but the Church that Jesus himself began. As the creed says that Church is, “one, holy, catholic, and apostolic.” It is not just anyone or everyone in that Church, but it is those to whom the authority has been given to lead the Church. That is the Magisterium. The Magisterium is the Pope in union with the bishops and they have been given the duty and responsibility to pass on to us the unchanged teachings of Jesus. When someone disagrees with the Church, they don’t disagree with just the Church, but they disagree with Christ himself.

The bible is a photo album and as such it does not contain everything that has come to pass. Scripture itself tells us this in John 21:25 –

“But there are also many other things which Jesus did, which, if they were written in detail, I expect that even the world itself would not contain the books that would be written.”

Scripture contains everything we need to know about salvation but scripture alone it not enough to properly understand it. We need both Holy Scripture and Sacred Oral Tradition to get a complete understanding of who Jesus is and the relationship he has with his Church.

God's Great Puzzle

Leaving Mass this weekend I found a white envelope sitting under the windshield wiper on my car. I knew without looking what it was. It was a letter from someone concerned for the salvation of my soul.

The letter begins –

“My Catholic friend; I’m writing you today concerning Roman Catholicism. I have studied the Holy Bible for over 34 years now. I feel compelled to share my findings here with you in a letter.”

What follows is no less than eight pages of scripture passages, single spaced in 8 font, telling me how the Catholic Church got it all wrong. Of course, the letter is anonymous. There is no return address and no means offered if I wanted to learn more. The person claimed to have a wealth of information gleaned from decades of study but didn’t want to talk to me directly about it

. I am reminded of a scene from the Rodney Dangerfield movie, “Back to School.” Thornton Melon had an assignment to do a book report on Kurt Vonnegut. Thornton didn’t understand the book so he hired Kurt Vonnegut himself to write the report on what the book was about. He received a failing grade on the paper because, as the teacher put it, “Whoever wrote the paper didn’t know the first thing about Kurt Vonnegut.”

The New Testament of the bible was written by those in the Catholic Church. The Catholic bible, from which all non-Catholic bibles have their source, was compiled by the Catholic Church. The Church has read, preached, and taught on the scriptures for the last two-thousand years. To say that it is the authority on what it wrote, compiled, and taught on for two millennia should go unquestioned. But, if we need to quote scripture about who has the authority we need to look no further than 1 Timothy 3:15 –

“…but in case I am delayed, I write so that you will know how one should act in the household of God, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and support of the truth.”

The Church is the pillar and support of the truth, not scripture. I will always take two-thousand years of authority stemming from the very beginning over a thirty-four-year independent study any day.

The bible is God’s great puzzle. Each verse of scripture is a piece in that puzzle. The pieces fit together only one way. One must look at all of the pieces in relation to the whole to see the complete picture portrayed. Looking at pieces individually or in small groups can easily lead one astray as to what the pieces truly mean.

The devil is one of the greatest scripture scholars. He was there when most of it took place. He is very cunning in getting people to look at an individual piece of the puzzle or a group of pieces and see in them something other than their true intended meaning. You can find a scripture verse to support just about any ideology. Scripture has been used and continues to be used to justify great evils.

A common non-Catholic Christian believe is that a person can read the bible and be inspired and guided to it’s true meaning by the spirit. If this were true, we would not have over forty-thousand different understandings of the bible. The statement is partially true, however. A person can read the bible and be guided by a spirit. That does not mean it is the Holy Spirit doing the guiding. The person who wrote me the letter most certainly has been led astray by a spirit other than the Holy Spirit.

Despite popular belief, Catholics are encouraged to read their bibles. They are encouraged to meditate on what they read. We even have a special way of doing this called Lexio Divina. Catholics are encouraged to study the bible alone and in groups. They are read the bible and have the Gospel proclaimed to them at every Mass, along with practical instruction from the clergy on how what was read applies to our lives today.

What a Catholic should not do is to try and interpret the bible for themselves, as the letter writer did. We have the Magisterium whose duty it is to give us the authoritative interpretation of what scripture means. Authority given to the Church by Jesus himself. It is ok to be inspired by scripture as long as the inspiration does not contradict official Church teaching. Where a contradiction occurs, we are to always accept what the Church teaches over personal opinion.

The bible is God’s great puzzle. It’s true beauty can only be seen by looking at it as a whole and not microfocus on any individual piece.

I Hold the Whole World in my Hands

There is one God.

With three distinct and individual persons; Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

The Father begot the Son and the Holy Spirit precedes from the Father and the Son.

All existence resides within God. Heaven, hell, purgatory, and the entire timeline of existence exists fully within God. For God, every moment of existence is now. Every place in existence is here.

All creation was created for Jesus. All was created through Jesus. He is before all else that is.

The Eucharist is Jesus. It is his body, blood, soul, and divinity. The Eucharist is true presence of Christ. Jesus, being God, has the fullness of all existence within him. Everything that has ever been created, exists now, or will come into creation, every person who has lived, lives now, or will live in the future, and every moment of time from the beginning until the end all exists within Jesus Christ.

When I hold the Eucharist, I literally hold all of existence in my hands. I hold every moment of time, every person, and everything that has or will be created, including myself. When I consume the Eucharist I am taking into my finite body the infinite.

Too great a mystery for my feeble mind to fully comprehend, yet all things are possible for God.

And my sorrow deeps for those who snatch the Eucharist from my hands as if it were nothing more than a Ritz cracker.

Novus Ordo or TLM

On July 16, 2021, Pope Francis issued Traditionis Custodes, a motu proprio on the use of the Roman Liturgy prior to the reform of 1970. Motu proprio is Latin for “on his own impulse”. Traditionis Custodes reversed the motu proprio Summorum Pontificum issued by Pope Benedict XVI on July 7, 2007.

In short, Summorum Pontificum gave priests the permission to say the Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) privately and pastors the permission to say it publicly if the need were present and for pastoral reasons. Traditionis Custodes gave the local ordinary (bishop) the sole ability to grant permission for the TLM to be offered, by whom, where, and when.

What Traditionis Custodes did not do is say that the TLM can no longer be offered. It can still be offered as a valid Mass as long as the local ordinary approves it. This has caused quite a stir among all Catholic circles. Some agree with the Pope, some do not. Some think it was the right move at the wrong time and others feel it wasn’t necessary at all.

Supporters of the TLM think that it is a more reverent Mass. It is mysterious, largely due to it being in a dead language few understand and even fewer speak correctly. The Novus Ordo feels common place, said in a common language. There is no doubt that it has caused many to lose the wonder of Mass. It is just my opinion, but I think if people actually understood and believed who they are standing before at Mass we would see some vastly different choices in things like clothing options and demeaner.

Both Masses are beautiful when done correctly amid reverent people whose hearts are full of love for God. Both Masses do the exact same thing; make present the supernatural reality of Christ’s sacrifice on Calvary. Because of this one is not better nor more valid than the other. They are different methods of transporting us to the exact same moment and location in time. In the end, that is the only thing that truly matters; that we are standing at the foot of the cross worshiping God with all creation.

So, what are we to do amid all the hubbub? Allow me to string some scriptural thoughts together and see where it leads us.

First let us look at the story of Naaman, commander of the army of King Aram from 2 Kings 5. Naaman had leprosy. He went to the prophet Elisha to be cured. Elisha instructed Naaman to go wash himself in the Jordan seven times and he would be cured. Naaman was furious because he expected that he would have to go off and do some great thing. Instead, he was told to go bath in a specific place.

God does not want us to always do great things. Sometimes it is the little things he wants us to do. We want to do great things so that we may think ourselves great. God prefers those who are humble over those who think themselves great.

On to 1 Samuel 15. Here we find the disobedience of King Saul. Samuel tells Saul that God prefers obedience over sacrifice. In fact, if we could be truly obedient to God there would be no need for sacrifice. Sacrifice is only needed due to our disobedience.

Lastly, let us look at Matthew 16: 18 and 19. You are Peter and upon this rock I shall build my Church. It is the passage where Jesus makes Peter the first Pope and gives him the authority to lead his Church. Pope Francis, as the successor to Peter, has the authority of Christ to lead the Church.

The ordinary form of worship of the Latin rite Catholic Church (Roman Catholic) is the Novus Ordo Mass. The TLM is retained as the extraordinary form of worship. Those who defiantly choose to participate in a TLM without the permission of their bishop put their desires above the instruction of the Church. To take that which God does not freely offer is the definition of sin. People who put their desires before that of the Church stand with people like Luther, Knox, and Calvin, who thought their opinion out-weighed that of the Church and her leadership to whom Christ has given all authority. The devil loves to use holy things to separate people from God by making them think their disobedience is actually a holy thing.

We live in rebellious times where everyone makes themselves their own President, Congress, judge, jury, and yes, even their own pope. Rightful authority is dismissed the instant it does not align with one’s opinion on a matter. God desires obedience over sacrifice. Jesus tells his disciples that if they love him they will follow his commands. He gave his authority to lead the Church to them and promised to be with us until the end of time. Those who oppose the rightful authority of the Church do not just oppose the Pope but oppose Christ himself. There is no reverence in disobeying Jesus no matter how reverently one does it.

Over All Lines

The Navy has a particular way that it ties its ships to the pier. This is done so the ship will be secure no matter what the sea state is. They use six lines (ropes) to do this.

Lines one and six go straight to the pier from the front and back of the ship respectively. These lines are of the largest diameter rope as they have the most important job. Lines two and four angle backwards to keep the ship from moving forwards and lines three and five angle forward to keep the ship from moving backwards. The six lines hold the ship fast to the pier and there is never any fear of the ship coming loose and floating away.

Now think of your soul as a ship and Christ the pier. The more lines you have tethering you to Jesus the more secure and stronger your faith will be. This biggest lines, line one and six, is the Mass and your participation in it. These are two separate things as one can attend Mass but never really participate in it. The greater your participation the bigger and stronger these lines become.

Lines two through five are the assisting lines. These lines assist and augment lines one and six. Lines two and four is our private prayer life. Line two is our formal prayer life – saying formal prayers like the ‘Our Father’, the Angelus, private devotions like the Rosary or the Divine Mercy Chaplet, or praying the Liturgy of the Hours. Our formal prayers are always combined with others saying the same prayers and presented as one universal prayer to the Father. These prayers, when heard in the supernatural, are powerful. Line four is our informal prayer life. This is the time we spend speaking to Jesus from our hearts. This is where we thank him for our blessing and share with him what is on our minds. This is where we spend time in silent reflection giving Jesus an opportunity to speak to us. God speaks to us through a still, small voice so it is important to carve out some time, no matter how short, to spend some quiet time each day listening for God’s voice in our lives. Eucharistic Adoration gives us that opportunity to sit with our Lord in silence and have a dialog with him.

But coming to Mass and saying your prayers are not enough. One does not make music simply by knowing how to play an instrument. The instrument must be played to make music. Saint James tells us that faith, without works, is truly dead. Our works, then, are also lines that tie us to Christ. Jesus gave us a new command to follow; to love one another as he has loved us. The way we begin to love one another is to first recognize the dignity inherent to every person. Dignity is God’s thumbprint on the human soul. It is not enough just to throw material things at people’s material needs. The primary need of every person, regardless of how rich or poor they may be, is love. To truly love someone is to will their good. We begin to love another when we see them as a person with dignity, who deserves our respect, and then by treating them in the way we want Jesus to treat us. Lines three and five are our works and deeds. These lines secure us to Christ and allow Christ to work through us in all we say and do. The stronger these lines and the more we allow Jesus to work through us, the greater our faith becomes.

Ships that are not secured to the pier drift aimlessly at sea. Many wash up on the rocks and are lost. How securely are you tied to the pier of Christ?

A Need for Leadership

The word sacrament comes from the Latin word sacramentum. A sacramentum was an oath sworn to the gods in an act of consecration. It was also the oath to the death a Roman soldier took to the emperor.

The Church defines a Sacrament as, “Sacraments are outward signs of inward grace, instituted by Christ and conferred by the Church for our sanctification."

One facet of the Sacraments is the oath to the death. We simply do not receive a Sacrament. Before we receive a Sacrament, we offer the Lord an oath to the death. The collateral we offer for these oaths are our very lives. If we violate our oath, we forfeit our life and we enter a state of mortal sin. If we do not repent of this sin and receive forgiveness for it before we die we will spend eternity in hell.

This is why a civilly divorced and remarried Catholic cannot receive the Holy Eucharist. In the marriage vows Catholics take an oath until death do us part. The collateral on that oath is their lives. When they divorce and remarried they forfeit this collateral, meaning they no longer have it to offer as collateral on any other Sacrament, such as receiving the Holy Eucharist.

When we present ourselves at communion, we are taking an oath to live for Christ and die for him if necessary. The minister of communion holds up the Eucharist and says the words, “The Body of Christ.” Our response is, “Amen.” We say this before receiving our Lord. This is where we take our oath to the death.

As a deacon, I am an ordinary minister of Holy Communion. I get to see a lot of interesting situations of people receiving. There are two that are common and that I would like to comment on.

We have many husbands and wives who present themselves together to receive communion. This is a beautiful statement of love when they do this. I will always give communion to the husband first and then to his wife. I have had a few times where the husband refuses to receive before his wife. He loves his wife so much that he wants her to receive Jesus before he does. This is well intentioned, but misguided.

Likewise, we have many families who come up to receive together. In almost every case the father of the family allows the children and his wife to receive before he does. Again, this is also well intentioned, but misguided.

When we come up to receive our Lord in the Sacrament of the Holy Eucharist we begin by pledging an oath to the death that we will live for Christ and die for him if necessary. This is a place where husbands and fathers need to lead their family, not follow. They need to show their families that this oath is something they should do.

It is commonly said that a husband’s or a father’s job is to get his wife and family to heaven. He does this by leading them, not pushing them. If terrorists were to take over a Mass and begin executing anyone who would not deny our Lord, a husband or father would be expected to lead the way and be an example to his wife and children how to die a good Christian death. What kind of husband or father would he be if he pushed his wife or children out to be executed before he is? It is not chauvinistic or womanizing in any way for a husband to lead his family. In reality it is just the opposite. It is the most loving thing he can do for them.

Authentic male leadership has been lost in our culture in this age. The evil one has convinced us that we must be equal in function in order to be equal in worth. This simply is not the case. Our worth in the eyes of God is not tied to our function. If we wish to honor him we need to learn to honor the function that he made us for.

If our culture is going to survive we need to restore males to the proper place of leadership within the family. The father is the head of the family. The evil one has destroyed the family by removing its head, the father. Every body that has been beheaded has no life within it. It is time for men to step up and lead in the way that Jesus did. Men need to lead through love and self-sacrifice for the other.

Husbands and fathers, lead your family to the Eucharist. Communion is not a buffet line where you allow your family to get fed first. You are taking an oath that you are presenting your life to cover. Show your family what that means and how to honor that oath.

Little Details Matter

There is a rule in screen writing that you never put in a detail that won’t be used later. James Bond movies are famous for this. Early on in every James Bond movie Q gives James the exact secret gadgets he will need to get out of a life and death situation later in the movie. These gadgets are never reused in any movie that follow.

Scripture is full of details that are often overlooked or are viewed simply as descriptions that have little importance later in the story. One such example is in the story of the raising of Lazarus. We are told that Lazarus was dead and in the tomb for four days. His sisters did not want the tomb opened because there would have been a stench by this time. This was to let us know that he has truly dead and not merely near death.

This scene in the story always reminds me of an Irish wake. The old tale goes that they would lay the body of a dead Irishman out on the table in his home for three days. People would come to visit but the main purpose was to make sure the person had really died and not had succumb to lead poisoning that leached into the beer from the pewter tanks it was stored in. It is probably nothing more than a wives’ tale but even wives’ tales have a grain of truth to them. I wonder how many Irishmen sat up in their coffins during their funerals.

One of the details in the story of Lazarus that is easily overlooked is the fact that Lazarus stumbles out of his tomb still wrapped securely in his burial cloths when Jesus beckons to him from outside. His sisters had to rush to his aid to free him from these cloths. Like a good Bond movie, this detail was not put into the story just to help us paint a mental picture of the scene. It points out a greater reality later in the story.

Fast forward to Easter Sunday. Peter and John enter the tomb where Jesus was laid on Good Friday. Scripture tells us that they saw the burial wrappings laying there and the cloth that covered Jesus’ head rolled up in another place. This is another place in scripture where the actual Greek text gives us a more complete understanding of what the disciples saw.

The burial cloth of Jesus was not just simply laying there as if it were taken off, folded up, and placed on the stone. It was laying there as if it were deflated, as if the body of Jesus simply disappeared from being. This is where the details of Lazarus’ resurrection become important.

If Jesus simply rose from the dead, he would have been still wrapped in his burial linens the way Lazarus was. The women who came to anoint Jesus on Sunday morning would have found him wrapped snug as a bug in a rug and would have to had freed our risen Lord. But that is not what was found.

The details we are given in scripture would indicate that the bloody and bruised body of our crucified Lord was transformed into his glorified body when he returned from the dead. His earthly body became no more when he took on his glorified body.

There are many who believe that the Shroud of Turin is the actual burial cloth spoken about in scripture. I am one of these people. The more science honestly studies the shroud the more it appears to be the genuine article. The image on the shroud is believed to be a 3D hologram of a man that fits the description of what Christ would have looked like when wrapped in his burial cloth. It is a photo negative just like the negatives we used to develop pictures from before the age of the cell phone camera. Scientists cannot explain how the image on the shroud was created and the best scientific guess right now is that the image was created by a blast of intense light that burned the image on the upper parts of the fibers that make up the cloth.

For those with unshakable faith, signs and wonders are not needed. For those without faith there is not a sign or wonder good enough to remove doubt. For those of us somewhere in the middle, we are given signs and wonders so that we may come to believe and have our faith grow.

My heart is full because the tomb is empty.

Supernatural Reality

My heart yearned to see the supernatural reality that I was part of. Then one day it happened, like a fog dissipating in the early morning light. Darkness slowly gave way to shadows as the world began to come alive. My senses heightened. My anticipation I could hardly contain.

I stood behind the Table of Sacrifice dressed in gold. The priest stood before the table. Not a priest or any priest, but every priest who had been ordained throughout all of time. They occupied the same space and the same time, both individually and together as a unity.

To their left and to their right stood the deacons. Not a deacon or the deacon, but every deacon who has ever been ordained. Like the priest, they occupied the same space and the same time, individually and together as a unity. It was with them I stood.

We were at the Sacrifice of Thanksgiving, the Mass. Not a Mass or any Mass but every Mass that has ever been said throughout all time, all happening at the same time in the same space.

As the supernatural reality came into focus my body began to tremble when it was revealed to me what I was a part of. The supernatural reality was superimposed on the veiled reality and everything appeared as two and as one.

In the altar I saw a hill and from the hill extended the tree of life. Hanging from the tree was the Christ, bloody, bruised, naked, and gasping for every breath he took. Before the tree, in the priest, I saw Jesus himself, glorified as he was during the transfiguration. His eyes were affixed heavenward as he offered that sacrifice of himself for all of humanity.

I looked right and left. Superimposed in the deacons I saw the angels of the heavenly court who assist Jesus with this sacrifice. Their wings spread wide as the deacons’ heads were bowed. Surrounding the altar was all of God’s creation, all of the heavenly hosts, and every person who has ever been created. I saw my family, those who passed long before I was born, and my heirs who would not be born until long after I pass. All gathered together in this time at this place. Calvary.

Then I did something I never have before. I looked down. Under the altar, beneath the cross there was a large hole. I crept to the edge and looked inside. It was the gateway to the abyss, to the very heart of hell itself. In the center of the abyss was a large throne and sitting on the throne was Lucifer. Surrounding him were the souls of the damned, those condemned to spend all eternity in the lake of fire.

Their hands were raised towards heaven and they cried in loud voices, “Lord, lord, save us!”

The Christ looked down from the cross and his eyes filled with tears. “You I do not know,” he said with a labored and agonizing breath.

“Through Him, with Him and in Him, in the unity of the Holy Spirit, all glory and honor is yours, almighty Father, for ever and ever.” I looked up and the priests were raising the Body and Blood of our Lord to heaven.

Jesus’ hands and gaze were raised towards heaven. “Father, I offer myself as sacrifice for the salvation and redemption of our creation. Let my blood wipe away all transgression and restore unity between us and humanity for ever more.”

With that, I heard all of creation, all of the heavenly hosts, and all of humanity throughout all time all proclaim in one great crescendo, “AMEN!”

The earth shook and Christ on the cross said, “It is finished.” His head fell limp and he breathed no more.

From the abyss came shrieks and wailing. The devil cried out in a loud voice as his defeat became final.

The veil was drawn over my eyes once more and all I could see was the priest and the altar and the Mass I was part of. As the priest raised the host in the Epiclesis, I could hear Jesus speaking directly to me.

“I did not give you this for you to keep for yourself. Give witness to others as to what you have seen and to draw as many back as you can. All will be at this. Those who are not at the altar or in the congregation will be in the abyss. It is for them I weep. It is not too late but the time is coming when repentance will no longer be possible.”

If more people understood the supernatural side of our Mass there would not be an open space in any Church throughout the world. I have the honor of standing where heaven touches the earth, in front of the cross, every time I get to assist as Mass. One day we all will get to see this reality with unveiled eyes. If you want to be looking at Jesus and not up at him come to love him now while you are given a chance. To know and love Jesus makes you want to repent of ever offending him through sin.

Casting Stones

January 20, 2021. For only the second time in this country’s history a Catholic was sworn in as our President. This happened amid cheers of joy by one half of our country and vile hatred by the other. As I watched the events leading up to this I couldn’t help but be filled with shame and disgust. We are the United States of America. We were the shining city on the hill other countries looked towards to see what freedom looks like. What they saw from us the past few months was a bunch of children throwing temper tantrums led by a President that acted more like a school yard bully than the leader of the most powerful nation this planet has ever seen.

What is happening now bothers me more than all of the shenanigans of the past election. President Biden is a baptized Catholic who attends Mass regularly. He holds beliefs that are contrary to Catholic teaching. His stance on abortion was all the reason I needed not to vote for him for President.

Everywhere I turn I see a growing demand by other Catholics that he be stripped of his Catholic identity. People demand that his bishop deny him communion while many others call for his excommunication altogether. To all of you who feel this way I only have one thing to say:

Let he without sin cast the first stone.

Every single one of us is a sinner. Every single one of us falls short of the glory of God. Cafeteria Catholic is a popular expression. It refers to any Catholic who picks and chooses which of the Church’s teachings they wish to follow. How many of those calling for President Biden’s excommunication cohabitate, masturbate, or use birth control? How many follow every Church teaching all of the time? How many are receiving the Eucharist unworthily themselves?

Many will cite Matthew 18: 15-18:

“Now if your brother sins, go and show him his fault in private; if he listens to you, you have gained your brother. But if he does not listen to you, take one or two more with you, so that on the testimony of two or three witnesses every matter be confirmed. And if he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church; and if he refuses to listen even to the church, he is to be to you as a Gentile and a tax collector. Truly I say to you, whatever you bind on earth shall have been bound in heaven; and whatever you loose on earth shall have been loosed in heaven.”

If we applied this fairly we would have a much smaller Church. We would have to kick out my friend who has decided that her reproductive right to contraception is none of the Church’s business. We would have to kick out my son who has decided to cohabitate because, “How else do you figure out if you are compatible for marriage?” We would have to kick out every Cafeteria Catholic who chooses their own desires over the teachings of the Church.

I do not want President Biden excommunicated. I don’t want to see his bishop deny him communion. All that does is create scandal and controversy we really do not need right now, as a Church and as a country. I pray that President Biden come to the realization that his actions are contrary to the Church’s teachings and voluntarily refrain from receiving our Lord in the Eucharist.

But make no mistake, President Biden is Catholic. He became Catholic the day he was baptized. I want him at Mass listening to the Word. One day he may even hear it. As Catholics, our job is to pray for him and for every single Catholic; that God replace our stony hearts with natural hearts that turn to him in love and repentance. President Biden will have to answer to God for those things he has not repented of, as will I, you, and every person who has ever existed. He does not answer to me.

Let he who has no sin cast the first stone. I don’t see our Blessed Mother with a rock in her hand so please drop yours as well.